IVP - Andy Unedited

January 12, 2017

Insider Jesus 2: Did the Reformation Make a Misstep?

God is active in all cultures around the world, even before Christianity or the Bible reach them. That's what William Dyrness contends in Insider Jesus (which I discussed here). If he is right, the implications go far beyond missionary efforts. They encompass how we should view our own faith.

We see this when we look back at the Reformation. For all its strengths and benefits, says Dyrness, the Reformation has also distorted some of our understanding of Christianity. How is this so?

The Insider Jesus.jpgmain changes the Reformation brought about was not so much one of belief but of practice, Dyrness suggests. Praying to saints, pilgrimages, novenas, rituals and what were considered superstitions of almost every kind were discouraged. Art, drama, paintings and architecture were also minimized or condemned. "If thinking is the primary locus of truth [as the Reformation suggested], all other embodied cultural forms must surely be inferior" (p. 10).

In their place came other practices--preaching, reading the Bible and learning catechisms. This had the effect of changing the emphasis from a wholistic, culture-embedded faith that combined internal devotion and external practice, to one that was largely internal (heart and mind) and separate from the wider world. One downside of this (which modernist and Enlightenment tendencies intensified) is that religion has for many decades now been portrayed as something private, separate from the public sphere. Indeed, many contend that private religion should have no bearing on culture or society.

Most of the rest of the world sees religion very differently. There is no division of private and public, of religion and society. For them, it is not strange at all that religious leaders should guide public policy. Because we Westerners already see religion and culture as separate spheres, we see no problem asking converts to separate from their culture and side with Christianity. But that may in fact uproot them from what God has already been doing in them and in their cultures. We may be working against God instead of with him.

While John Calvin.jpgI am sympathetic to the direction Dyrness is going, I think he unfairly makes the Reformation his main whipping boy. Certainly the Greek influence on the early centuries of the church is also important. When Judaism had no creed except possibly for the very brief Shema, how else can we explain the proliferation of fixed summaries of belief from the Apostles' Creed to Athanasius? The Reformation stood in the tradition of the early church in this regard.

Dyrness belatedly and indirectly acknowledges this (pp. 142-43). And it is true that lived Christianity was generally more wholistic in the centuries leading up to the Reformation. Nonetheless, the magisterial Reformation leaders claimed that they were going back to the sources, back to the early church fathers in their pursuit of pure Christianity. And in regard to the emphasis of the early church on the early creeds, indeed they were.

Though I wish Dyrness had nuanced his analysis of the Reformation a bit more, he is nonetheless on a very helpful track. His book is an important, profound and needed analysis of Scripture, theology, culture, missionary activity and how we ourselves practice our Christian faith.

Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:31 AM | Comments

January 5, 2017

Insider Jesus

In the midst of the explosion of Christianity around the world, some strange and unusual expressions of faith are emerging.

Continue reading "Insider Jesus"
Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:14 AM | Comments (2)

December 20, 2016

Isaiah's Greatest Hits

Every Christmas and Easter Handel's Messiah treats us to the greatest hits in the book of Isaiah. We can hardly help but sing along when we read such texts as:

Continue reading "Isaiah's Greatest Hits"
Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:07 AM | Comments

December 15, 2016

Feeling Bad a Whole New Way

Good news for all of us racked by guilt as a result of being raised Jewish, Catholic or Protestant! There is a whole different way to feel bad about ourselves, and it is called honor-shame.

Continue reading "Feeling Bad a Whole New Way"
Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:09 AM | Comments

December 13, 2016

Through Old Testament Eyes 4: Who Are the Chosen Ones?

Election is controversial. Of course, I'm talking about the Christian doctrine, not any recent political events.

For five hundred years Protestants have gone back and forth on the topic of predestination and all its implications. The effect for sensitive souls, however, can be to worry and wonder, "Am I one of the elect? Am I one of the chosen, or will I somehow fall outside the bounds of grace?"

Continue reading "Through Old Testament Eyes 4: Who Are the Chosen Ones?"
Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:10 AM | Comments

December 6, 2016

Through Old Testament Eyes 3: Getting the Whole Story

When I first saw Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings I was struck by Howard Shore's musical score, especially his Shire theme. Immediately I noticed that as it begins we can sing right along the opening words of "This Is My Father's World" before it takes off with Shore's own melody. At first I wondered, "Doesn't he know that's a famous hymn tune?" But then it hit me. Of course he does, and he's using it on purpose.

Continue reading "Through Old Testament Eyes 3: Getting the Whole Story"
Posted by Andy Le Peau at 10:11 AM | Comments (1)

Get Email Updates

You'll get an email whenever a new entry is posted to Andy Unedited

Blog Favs

Subscribe to Feeds

Got a Book Idea?

Please follow our submissions guidelines. We cannot respond to book proposals or inquiries within the context of this blog.

Get to Know IVP

book cover"Some publishers tell you what to believe. Other publishers tell you what you already believe. But InterVarsity Press helps you believe," says J. I. Packer. Andy Le Peau and Linda Doll describe how this came to be a hallmark of InterVarsity Press in Heart. Soul. Mind. Strength, an anecdotal history spanning the sixty years from the founding of IVP in 1947 to the present day.